COMMUNICATIONS CAPITAL PROJECT COMMITTEE
July 23, 2002, 11:30 A.M.
SCOTT HEYMAN CONFERENCE ROOM
PRESENT: B. Blanchard, P. Penniman, M. Robertson, R. Booth
ABSENT: G. Totman
STAFF: S. Whicher, County Administrator; L. Shurtleff, Director,
Emergency Response; J. Wood, County Attorney; W. Skinner, Public Information
Coordinator; N. Jayne, Executive Assistant, E Marx, K Borgella
GUESTS: Chief Ken Lansing, John Hill, Varna Fire Department,
Dooley Kiefer, D. McDonald
CALL TO ORDER
The meeting opened at 11:32 a.m.
ADDITIONS TO/DELETIONS FROM THE AGENDA
None
APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF JUNE 25, 2002
It was MOVED by Mr. Booth, seconded by Mr. Penniman, and unanimously
adopted by voice vote by members present, to approve the June 25, 2002
minutes with the recommended changes.
Chairs Report/DOT Relocation B Blanchard,
E Marx, D. McDonald, K Borgella
Ms. Blanchard gave a brief history of this project. It began in July
1997, with Stu Stein, then County Board chair, talking with Herman Sieverding,
then on the City Planning staff, and pointing out the value of the DoT
site on the waterfront and suggesting it could be put to better community
use. Since then we have been through three different DoT regional directors,
and this has been discussed with all of them. Finally, on Dec. 19, 2000,
the Board of Representatives passed a resolution supporting the relocation.
Ms. Blanchard said that $3.0 million is available from NY State this year
through Senator Seward’s efforts plus at least $700,000 from NYS DOT.
The planning department has developed a plan to carry out the project with
a Local Development Corporation (LDC) established and given the responsibility
to oversee the project. The City of Ithaca has a contract with the
National Development Council (NDC), which acts as the City’s technical
advisor on complicated economic development projects. The local NDC contact
is Kevin McLaughlin. The NDC can assist the county and the city in
establishing the not-for-profit LDC model and refine the budget. The NDC
would also have their architectural associates scope out the building and
refine the budget to arrive at a guaranteed maximum price.
The redevelopment of the Third Street site would most likely be accomplished
through a RFP process to choose a developer that will bring the most to
the local economy.
The DOT will not be the developer of the new facility; they are looking
for a turnkey solution. DoT may be interested in a long-term lease, which
might cost DoT more in the long run, but would require less money upfront.
The Local Development Corporation could take the lead on planning and construction.
NDC will provide guidance on this. The new facility construction will require
no local share as it is to be funded by the Seward funds, the sale of the
property and the DOT funding. A resolution will be developed and
put to vote before the next board meeting to create a capital project with
no local share and to authorize the appraisal of the site. Ms. Smithers
will need to bring it to the budget committee. Appraisals need to
be obtained for the Dryden site including site configurations - Mr. Wood
will call Martha Armstrong at TCAD to set up the site visit. D. Kiefer
asked if it is possible to have the LDC build the DoT site quickly and
Tompkins County take title to the old site, and then lease rather than
sell that site to a developer. B. Blanchard said yes, at this point anything
is possible. R. Booth asked why have the county take title; why not just
turn the land over to the City, since they have lots of development expertise
and would do a good job. B. Blanchard noted that is not a widely shared
view. M. Robertson asked if that site would need a toxicity study. R. Booth
said he has heard that Third Street site has structural soil problems.
Update on Paging Project, United Radio Contract Extension
M Shakarjian
Received the propagation maps in GIS format from United Radio. The
frequency application has been forwarded to the FCC. A resolution
will be developed for the next committee meeting to enter into an agreement
with United Radio for the paging project.
911 Building Project Status
S. Whicher
Lansing has preliminarily approved the site for building. When
Ms. Shakarjian obtains drainage documentation she will make a presentation
to the Village planning committee. The proposed project schedule
reflects a significant time delay. The permits required are an agreement
with the village, a permit from DEC and FAA. The contract with the
architect is being sent out July 23, 2002. Mr. Whicher will work
on accelerating the timeline.
The Village of Lansing is aware of the potential tower site. The
FAA regulations are 150 feet so the solution is a 125 ft tower next to
the 911 building. The Village’s zoning ordinance requires a fall
zone so Tompkins County will provide documentation that the tower will
collapse and therefore should not be subject to the fall zone ordinance.
Tony Egner and Motorola met to discuss the equipment in the new facility.
Interested equipment vendors will receive a sketch to assure the equipment
will fit the design.
PSCS RFP Status Report S. Whicher
MACOM wants an extension because they don’t think they can give us
the best price prior to the SWN opening. If MACOM wins the bid with
SWN then the local governments would be able to get the state price.
Their design is confidential and not to be shared with outside vendors.
The committee agrees that Tompkins County will not extend the RFP deadline,
but Mr. Wood has written a proposal to address their confidentiality issues.
Mr. Whicher is confident that the state will continue to make suggestions
and recommendations to prevent Tompkins County from building a non-integrated
system with the SWN. He met with Hanford Thomas in Albany and received
a verbal commitment that Tompkins County will have a full partnership.
Tompkins County is now in receipt of a letter on the possibility of sharing
frequencies. Mr. Whicher discussed the possibility of expanding the
collaboration to include paging and incorporating the NYS Regional Dispatch
in the Tompkins County Consolidated Dispatch Center.
To Do:
Provide tower documentation to the Village of Lansing and information
on drainage mitigation.
Mikel Shakarjian will develop a resolution to enter into a contract
with United Radio for the paging project.
Jonathan Wood will contact Martha Armstrong to set up a visit to the
proposed DOT site.
A resolution creating the capital project for the DOT Relocation will
be prepared. Committee will meet at 4:00 prior to the Board meeting on
the 6th.
New Business
No new business.
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 1:12 p.m.
Submitted by Norma Jayne
|